BG3 is better in almost every single way. I think maybe (maybe!) they had their hands just a little bit tied by the D&D ruleset, but honestly I wouldn't call that hand-tying, just a creative choice.
If you wanted to make the argument that Divinity: OS1/OS2 was a better game because it was 100% Larian's vision, then I could get behind that. They used their own game engine, their own game world, class structure, ruleset, etc.
But I wouldn't say BG3 is a worse game for any of the reasons you listed. The story is amazing, the voice acting is impeccable, the visuals are top-notch and beautiful, the music is incredible, the gameplay and mechanics are solid.
The only real objective criticism you can make against it is that it has some bugs and sometimes, when all the various mechanics are at play, things don't exactly work out right (it's almost like it get's overwhelmed). Small grievance, though, in my opinion.
It is for the most part a perfect game, and one of the best in recent memory (if not one of the best ever).
*Some people saying the combat in Divinity OS1/OS2 is better, yeah, I can maybe agree with that. You could get really creative with OS1 and OS2 and while you can get creative with BG3, it's more exploitive than creative (i.e. pushing people off ledges).
Log in to comment