@eoten said:
@Maroxad said:
@BlackShirt20 said:
@netracing: Conservatives are concerned. Not freak out, huge difference.
Bottom line, everything about miss Elliot is female. Just because she “feels” different is irrelevant in the real world. If people wanna play dress up and pretend to be men, women, horses, cats, whatever...... do it. But keep it out of the pubic eye. No reason to be forced to play into someone’s delusions and possible serious mental illness.
I mean, 5’0 106lbs at 33, yeah that’s definitely a dude. LOL.
Really? Using height?
- There are adult men shorter than that, is Chandra female too?
- Or a decent chunk of males on r/short?
- Or Danny DeVito? Who stands at 4'10.
- Or how about Super Mario, who stands at 5'1? Is he female too?
- Or how about the entire Pygmy populace? Of whom the average height is 4'11 for males?
No offense, but I have seen a lot of bad arguments before against transgender people (they are all rooted in a 5th grade level of understanding of biology), but the one you used right here is the single worst argument I have heard.
Edit: Before you or anyone else embarrass yourself any further, read this https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/voices/stop-using-phony-science-to-justify-transphobia/. It may be a blog, so I believe it is how you people get your information these days. Perfect match!
Keep it up and you'll be a mental gymnastics gold medalist. Holy shit. You'll do anything to convince yourself a woman is a man just because she says she is even though you clearly know it isn't the case. We call that "cognitive dissonance." You act like it's wrong for someone to disagree with her.
You know what a similar mental disorder, as classified by psychologists, is to gender dysphoria? Body integrity dysphoria. You know, the mental illness where people see themselves as amputees, then remove their own limbs to fit that world view of themselves. Tell me, if someone with two arms and two legs WALKS up to you and claims to be missing a leg you can clearly see them standing on, what mental gymnastics will you put yourself through to believe them? Will the left call that hate speech as well if we disagreed with their assertions?
Yeah, the "pro science" left disagrees with decades of medical research and thousands of doctors, biologists, neurologists, psychologists, psychiatrists, and more the moment it is convenient for them to fabricate a new class of victim they can pretend to give a shit about every election year or when they can weaponize it against groups such as Christians. Meanwhile their's is a group that has one of the highest rates of suicide regardless of surgeries or perceived social acceptance and could really do with some actual help they'll never receive because they're more useful to the left as political tools.
What is a man? What is a woman?
Well, we have never had any issues in the past calling women with Swyer Syndrome women, despite the fact that they have XY chromosomes. So I dont think many people particularly care much about the genome of other people. Now Phenotypes, this is a common way to define someone as a man or a woman, but here is the thing, our phenotypes, even our phenotypical sex, can be changed. Medical science has come far enough to be able to change the phenotypic sex. Gender? This is another way. Sufficiently androgenous people are still referred to either as he or she, and that is done via their gender. How they express themselves.
Gender Dysphoria is a bit different from Body Integrity Dysphoria... you know. Because when it comes to gender, it is more psychological, sociological, rather than physical. Learn to differentiate Sex and Gender.
The left doesnt disagree with the medical consensus, because transgenders being valid have been accepted for DECADES now. Just ask the AMA, WMA and WHO. And many, many more, especially in psychological ones. No one is weaponizing transgender people against christians, at least no one I know of. In fact, Christians tend to be some of my most common allies on this topic, while the "Skeptic" Community (atheists) tend to be the most common demographic I get into arguments with on this very topic. Stop conspiracymongering, it doesnt help your cause.
I am defending transgender rights, not only because it is the right thing to do. But for anyone above a middle school level of understanding of biology, would have done the same. And while there are some politicians who are merely trying to cash in on it, the majority of left wingers do so because they like me, feel like it is the right thing to do.
Log in to comment